Institute for Maritime and Ocean Affairs

www.imoa.ph

Historical Truths and Lies: Scarborough Shoal in Ancient Maps

A Cartographic Exhibit
Based on the 06 June 2014 Lecture of
Supreme Court Senior Associate Justice Antonio T. Carpio

Interactive Map Instructions
Click on the image to explore the map in detail. You can zoom in to see intricate details and pan left, right, top, or bottom. Press ESC on your keyboard to exit the interactive map.

 Carta Hydrographica Y Chorographica de las Yslas Filipinas

a112_.8407.7734
Published in 1734 in Manila by the Jesuit Pedro Murillo, this is the oldest map that gives a name to “Panacot” shoal. “Panacot” is the Tagalog word for threat or danger. This map names two Filipinos, Francisco Suarez who drew the map and Nicolas dela Cruz Bagay who engraved it. This map is considered the “mother of all Philippine maps.” This digital reproduction is from the U.S. Library of Congress (Catalog No. 2013585226; Digital ID g8060 ct003137)

Map attached to China’s Notes Verbale Nos. CML/17/2009 and CML/18/2009

r_.768.1096

Official Chinese Map of the South China Sea with the nine-dotted line

s_.768.1269

“Maps merely constitute information which varies in accuracy from case to case; of themselves, and by virtue solely of their existence, they cannot constitute a territorial title, that is, a document endowed by international law with intrinsic legal force for the purpose of establishing territorial rights.”

Burkina Faso/Republic of Mali (1986 I.C.J. 554)


Thus, a state cannot enlarge its rights under international law by its own unilateral acts or domestic legislation. Yet, this is exactly what China did in 1947 when China drew its nine- dashed line map in the South China Sea, claiming as basis historical facts.

Despite the irrelevance of historical facts to present-day maritime claims under the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea, ancient maps of China made by Chinese authorities, Chinese individuals or foreigners, and ancient maps of the Philippines made by Westerners, Philippine authorities or individuals, vividly present the actual historical facts in the South China Sea.

Hua Yi Tu” or Map of China and the Barbarian Countries

hua-yi-tu_.4237.4500
Hua Yi Tu” or Map of China and the Barbarian Countries(4237×4500) Engraved in stone in Fuchang in 1136 AD during the Song Dynasty, this map of China was published in 1903(?) in France based on a rubbing of the stone engraving. The stone map is now in the Forest of Stone Steles Museum in Xi’an, China.
This map shows Hainan Island as the southernmost territory of China.
The annotations on the sides of this map are not part of the stone engraving.

This digital reproduction is from the U.S. Library of Congress (Catalogue No.2002626771; Digital ID g7820 ct000284).

“DA MING HUN YI TU” or the Great Ming Dynasty Amalgamated Map

c_.6400.2157
“DA MING HUN YI TU” or the Great Ming Dynasty Amalgamated Map (895×786) Published in 1389(?) during the Ming Dynasty, this map is painted in color on silk.
The map shows Hainan Island as the southernmost territory of China.
The original of the map is with the First Historical Archive of China in Beijing. This digital reproduction is from Wikimedia Commons, which sourced its copy from the library of the Hong Kong Baptist University. (http://geog.hkbu.edu.hk/ geog1150/chinese/catalog/am31_map1.htm).

“DA MING YU DI TU” or the Atlas of the Ming Empire

c_.6400.2157
“DA MING YU DI TU” or the Atlas of the Ming Empire (6408×2160) Published between 1547 and 1559 by the Ming Dynasty. The map shows the then 13 provinces of China during the Jianjing period. Taiwan is not included and Macau is not marked.
The map shows Hainan Island as the southernmost territory of China.
This digital reproduction is from the U.S. Library of Congress (Catalog No. 2002626776; Digital ID g7820m gct00125).

Since the start of the Song Dynasty in 960 AD until the end of the Qing Dynasty in 1912, or for almost a millennium, the southernmost territory of China has always been Hainan Island based on all official and unofficial maps of China.

And as late as 1932, the Chinese Government in a Note Verbale to France reiterated to the world that the southernmost territory of China is Hainan Island.

“TIAN DI TU” or the Atlas of Heaven and Earth

d_.5120.3389
“TIAN DI TU” or the Atlas of Heaven and Earth (5120×3389) Published in 1601 by Junheng Zuo during the Ming Dynasty.
This map shows Hainan Island as the southernmost territory of China.
This digital reproduction is from the U.S. Library of Congress (Catalog No. 200262625; Digital ID g7820m gct00225

“KUN YU WAN GUO QUAN TU” or A Map of the Myriad Countries of the World

e_.4096.1655
“KUN YU WAN GUO QUAN TU” or A Map of the Myriad Countries of the World (4096×1655) Published in Beijing in 1602 by the Ming Dynasty. The Jesuit priest Matteo Ricci created this world map upon request of the Ming Emperor Wanli. Ricci was assisted by Zhong Wentao, Li Zhizao, and other Chinese scholars.
This map shows Hainan Island as the southernmost territory of China.
This digital reproduction is from the U.S. Library of Congress (Catalog No. 2010585650; Digital ID g3200 ex000006Za,b and g3200m gex00001).

Selden Map of China

f_.4352.2468
“SELDEN MAP OF CHINA” This map was bequeathed by John Selden to the Bodleian Library of the University of Oxford in 1659. Published sometime between 1606 and 1624 during the Ming Dynasty. The maker of the map is an unknown Chinese. The map shows China, South Asia, Southeast Asia, and East Asia. The South China Sea is conspicuously at the center of the map.
This map shows Hainan Island as the southernmost territory of China.
This digital reproduction is from the Bodleian Library of the University of Oxford (http://seldenmap.bodleian. ox.ac.uk/map).

“DA QING WAN NIAN YI TONG TIAN XIA QUAN TU” or The Great Qing Dynasty’s Complete Map of All Under Heaven

f_.4352.2468
“DA QING WAN NIAN YI TONG TIAN XIA QUAN TU” or The Great Qing Dynasty’s Complete Map of All Under Heaven (4352×2468) Published in China in 1811 by the Qing Emperor Jiaqing. This map shows Hainan Island as the southernmost territory of China. This digital reproduction is from the U.S. Library of Congress (Catalog No. gm71005018; Digital ID g3200 ct003403).


“DA QING WAN NIAN YI TONG DI LI QUAN TU”
or the Complete Geographical Map of the Great Qing Dynasty

g_.4352.2471
“DA QING WAN NIAN YI TONG DI LI QUAN TU” or the Complete Geographical Map of the Great Qing Dynasty (4352×2471) Published in China between 1814 and 1816 by Qianren Huang.
This map shows Hainan Island as the southernmost territory of China.
Revised edition based on the original map drawn by Huang Qianren in 1767. This digital reproduction is from the U.S. Library of Congress (Catalog No. gm71005060; Digital ID g7820 ct002256).

“GUANGDONG TONG SHENG SHUI DAO TU”
or Map of the Waterways of Guangdong Province

h_.5888.3338
“GUANGDONG TONG SHENG SHUI DAO TU” or Map of the Waterways of Guangdong Province (5888×3338) Published sometime after 1815 by an unknown Chinese publisher. <
This map shows Hainan Island as the southernmost part of Guangdong province.
This digital reproduction is from the U.S. Library of Congress (Catalog No. gm71002467; Digital ID g7823g ct003406).

“GUANGDONG QUAN TU” or the Complete Map of Guangdong Province

j_.2160.1818
“GUANGDONG QUAN TU” or the Complete Map of Guangdong Province (2160×1818) Published in 1864 in Wuchang, China by Hubei Sheng and Guan Shu Ju.
This map shows Hainan Island as the southernmost part of Guangdong province.
This digital reproduction is from the U.S. Library of Congress (Catalogue No. gm71005120; Digital ID g7823g ct003391).

“DA QING ER SHI SAN SHENG YU DI QUAN TU” or the Complete Map of the Twenty- Three Provinces of the Great Qing Dynasty

l_.2304.2108
“DA QING ER SHI SAN SHENG YU DI QUAN TU” or the Complete Map of the Twenty- Three Provinces of the Great Qing Dynasty (2304×2108) 1885 AD “Da Qing Er Shi San Sheng Yu Di Quan Tu” Published sometime after 1885 in China by the Qing Dynasty.
This map shows Hainan Island as the southernmost territory of China.
This digital reproduction is from the U.S. Library of Congress (Catalog No. gm71005068; Digital ID g7820 ct003427).

“GUANGDONG QUAN SHENG SHUI LU YU TU” or Map of the Waterways and Roads in Guangdong Province

m_.6144.5005
 “GUANGDONG QUAN SHENG SHUI LU YU TU” or Map of the Waterways and Roads in Guangdong Province (6144×5005) Published in 1887(?) in China by Li Zhongpei. This map shows that Hainan Island is the southernmost part of Guangdong province. On the upper left side of the map, the annotations of Li Zhongpei state: “Qiongzhou (name of Hainan Island at that time) is far from the mainland, has a coastline of more than 1,400 li (unit of distance in Chinese), and is the territory (of China) that ships navigating to China will encounter when coming from Southeast Asia.” This digital reproduction is from the U.S. Library of Congress (Catalog No. gm71005159; Digital ID g7823g ct003392).

“HUANG CHAO ZHI SHENG YU DI QUAN TU” or the Qing Empire’s Complete Map of All Provinces (3441×2972) 1896 AD “Huang Chao Zhi Sheng Yu Di Quan Tu”

n_.3441.2972
“HUANG CHAO ZHI SHENG YU DI QUAN TU” or the Qing Empire’s Complete Map of All Provinces (3441×2972) 1896 AD “Huang Chao Zhi Sheng Yu Di Quan Tu” Published in 1896 in China by Peilan Li.
This map shows Hainan Island as the southernmost territory of China.
This digital reproduction is from the U.S. Library of Congress (Catalog No. gm71005083; Digital ID g7820 ct003428).

“ZHONG HUA GUO CHI DI TU”

o_.4352.3145
“ZHONG HUA GUO CHI DI TU” (4352×3145) Published in 1929 in Beijing by Hebei Sheng and Gong Shang Ting. The map mentions the treaties signed by China and the harbors opened to foreign powers.
This map shows Hainan Island as the southernmost territory of China.
This digital reproduction is from the U.S. Library of Congress (Catalog No. 2007628129; Digital ID g7821f ct002301).


“ZHONGHUA MIN GUO FEN SHENG XIN TU” or the Map of the Provinces of China

q_.6144.4556
“ZHONGHUA MIN GUO FEN SHENG XIN TU” or the Map of the Provinces of China (6144×4556) Published in 1933(?) in Wuchang, China by Ya Xin Di Xue She.
This map shows Hainan Island as the southernmost territory of China.
This digital reproduction is from the U.S. Library of Congress (Catalog No. 2006629696; Digital ID g7821f ct002303).

“CARTE EXACTE DE TOUTES LES PROVINCES, VILLES, BOURGS, VILLAGES ET RIVIERES DU VASTE ET PUISSANT EMPIRE DE LA CHINE” or An Accurate Map of All the Provinces, Cities, Towns, Villages and Rivers of the Vast and Powerful Chinese Empire

t_.2560.2138
“CARTE EXACTE DE TOUTES LES PROVINCES, VILLES, BOURGS, VILLAGES ET RIVIERES DU VASTE ET PUISSANT EMPIRE DE LA CHINE” or An Accurate Map of All the Provinces, Cities, Towns, Villages and Rivers of the Vast and Powerful Chinese Empire (2560×2138) Published in 1700(?) in Leiden, Netherlands by Johannes Nieuhof who made the map before his death in 1672.
This map shows Hainan Island as the southernmost territory of China.
This digital reproduction is from the U.S. Library of Congress (Catalog No. 87691057; Digital ID g7810 ct002857).

“CARTE LA PLUS GENERALE ET QUI COMPREHEND LA CHINE, LA TARTARIE CHINOISE, ET LE THIBET” or A General Map that Includes China, Chinese Tartary and Tibet

a110_.9772.6686
“CARTE LA PLUS GENERALE ET QUI COMPREHEND LA CHINE, LA TARTARIE CHINOISE, ET LE THIBET” or A General Map that Includes China, Chinese Tartary and Tibet (9772×6686) Created in 1734 (as shown on the map) in Paris by Jean Baptiste Bourguignon D’Anville. D’Anville was then the Royal Cartographer of France and had access to the works of the Jesuit cartographers in China through his friend the French Jesuit Du Halde, who was a specialist on China. As the map itself states, the map was taken from surveys made by the Jesuit missionaries from 1708-1716 upon instructions of the Emperor Kangxi of the Qing Dynasty.
This map shows Hainan Island as the southernmost territory of China.
This digital reproduction is from the National Library of Australia (Bib ID 2333624, Map Section at RM 3521).

Scarborough Shoal is more than 500 NM from Hainan Island, at the other end of the South China Sea.

 “CARTE DE L’EMPIRE DE LA CHINE, DE LA TARTARIE CHINOISE, ET DU ROYAUME DE CORÉE, AVEC LES ISLES DU JAPON”

a120_.9728.6679
 “CARTE DE L’EMPIRE DE LA CHINE, DE LA TARTARIE CHINOISE, ET DU ROYAUME DE CORÉE, AVEC LES ISLES DU JAPON” Published in 1787 in Paris by Rigobert Bonne.
This map shows ‘Scarboro’ shoal.
This digital reproduction is from the private collection of Atty. Anne Marie Corominas of Manila and Cebu.

“CARTE DE L’EMPIRE CHINOIS ET DU JAPON” or A French Map of the Chinese Empire together with Japan

v_.3840.2840
“CARTE DE L’EMPIRE CHINOIS ET DU JAPON” or A French Map of the Chinese Empire together with Japan (3840×2840) Published in 1833 in Paris by Conrad Malte- Brun.
This map shows Hainan Island as the southernmost territory of China.
This digital reproduction is from Wikimedia Commons (http:// en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:L%27Empire_Chinois_et_ du_Japon_%281833%29.jpg).

All the maps of the Philippines, from 1636 to 1940, a period of 304 years, consistently show Scarborough Shoal, whether named or unnamed, as part of the Philippines.

CHINA VETERIBUS SINARUM REGIO NUNC INCOLIS TAME DICTA

a100_.1536.1232
“CHINA VETERIBUS SINARUM REGIO NUNC INCOLIS TAME DICTA” (1536×1232) Published in Frankfurt in 1636 by map maker Matthaus Merian. This map shows China, Korea, Japan, Taiwan and Northern Luzon.
On the western side off the coast of Central Luzon, there is an unnamed shoal below the words “P. de Mandato.” The Spanish phrase “P. de Mandato” means the point of command – which implies there was a Spanish military garrison in that coastal place. The unnamed shoal off this coastal place would later be called “Panacot” by the Jesuit Pedro Murillo.
This digital reproduction is from Barry Lawrence Ruderman Antique Maps, Inc. (http://www. raremaps.com/gallery/detail/36716).

CARTE GENERALE DES INDES ORIENTALES ET DES ISLES ADIACENTES

a103_.1792.1463
“CARTE GENERALE DES INDES ORIENTALES ET DES ISLES ADIACENTES” (1792×1219) Published in Paris in 1650 by the map maker Pierre Mariette.
On the western side off the coast of Central Luzon, there is an unnamed shoal below the words “P. de Mandato.” This unnamed shoal would later be called Panacot.
This digital reproduction is from Barry Lawrence Ruderman Antique Maps, Inc. (http://www. raremaps.com/gallery/detail/30701/Carte_ Generale_Des_Indes_Orientales_et_des_ Isles_Adi acentes/Mariette.html).

TABULA INDIAE ORIENTALIS

a105_.1536.1254
“TABULA INDIAE ORIENTALIS” (1536×1254) On the western side off the coast of Central Luzon, there is an unnamed shoal below the words “P. de Mandato.” This unnamed shoal would later be called Panacot.
This digital reproduction is from Barry Lawrence Ruderman Antique Maps, Inc. (http://www. raremaps.com/gallery/archivedetail/0555/Tabula_Indiae_ Orientalis/De%20Wit.html).

INDIAE ORIENTALIS NEC NON INSULARUM ADIACENTUM NOVA DESCRIPTIO

a106_.2048.1684
“INDIAE ORIENTALIS NEC NON INSULARUM ADIACENTUM NOVA DESCRIPTIO” (2048×1684) Published in Amsterdam in 1670 by Nicholaus Visscher.
On the western side off the coast of Central Luzon, there are two unnamed shoals below the words “P. de Mandato.” One of these two shoals would later be called Panacot.
This digital reproduction is from Barry Lawrence Ruderman Antique Maps, Inc. (https://www.raremaps.com/ gallery/detail/35549/ Indiae_Orientalis_nec_ non_Insularum_Adiacentium_Nova_
Descript io/Visscher.html).

A NEW MAP OF EAST INDIA

a107_.1536.1193
“A NEW MAP OF EAST INDIA” (1536×1193) Published in London in 1676 by John Speed. On the western side off the coast of Central Luzon, there is an unnamed shoal below the words “P. de Mandato.” This unnamed shoal would later be called Panacot.
This digital reproduction is from Barry Lawrence Ruderman Antique Maps, Inc. (https://www.raremaps.com/gallery/detail/32192/A_ New_Map_of_East_India/ Speed.html).

INDIA ORIENTALIS ET INSULARUM ADIACENTUM ANTIQUA ET NOVA DESCRIPTIO

a109_.1536.1335
“INDIA ORIENTALIS ET INSULARUM ADIACENTUM ANTIQUA ET NOVA DESCRIPTIO” (1536×1335) Published in Leiden, Netherlands in 1697 by Philip Cluverius.
On the western side off the coast of Central Luzon, there is an unnamed shoal below the words “P. de Mandato.” This unnamed shoal would later be called Panacot.
This digital reproduction is from Barry Lawrence Ruderman Antique Maps, Inc. (http:// www.raremaps.com/gallery/detail/36938/ Indiae_Orientalis_et_Insularum
_Adiacentum_ Antiqua_et_Nova_Descriptio/
Cluverius.html).

Carta Hydrographica Y Chorographica de las Yslas Filipinas

a112_.8407.7734
 “Carta Hydrographica Y Chorographica de las Yslas Filipinas” (8407×7734) Published in 1734 in Manila by the Jesuit Pedro Murillo, this is the oldest map that gives a name to “Panacot” shoal. “Panacot” is the Tagalog word for threat or danger. This map names two Filipinos, Francisco Suarez who drew the map and Nicolas dela Cruz Bagay who engraved it. This map is considered the “mother of all Philippine maps.”
This digital reproduction is from the U.S. Library of Congress (Catalog No. 2013585226; Digital ID g8060 ct003137)

MAPA DE LAS YSLAS PHILIPINAS

a111_.3840.5622
“MAPA DE LAS YSLAS PHILIPINAS [cartographic material]” (3840×5622) Published in 1744 in Manila by the Jesuit Pedro Murillo Velarde. A second and smaller edition of the “Carta Hydrographica y Chorographica de las Yslas Filipinas.” This 1744 Murillo map, reduced version of the 1734 Murillo map, does not have the vignettes or scenes of people and places in the archipelago that appear in the 1734 map. The map is signed by the engraver, Nicholas dela Cruz Bagay. “Panacot” shoal is shown as in the 1734 map. This digital reproduction is from the National Library of Australia (Bib ID 1958890, map G8061. S1 1744).

INSULÆ PHILIPPINÆ EX AUTOGRAPHO, MANILÆ

a116_.9216.11655
“INSULÆ PHILIPPINÆ EX AUTOGRAPHO, MANILÆ” Published in 1748 in Vienna by Fernando Valdés Tamòn and Leopold Kaliwoda.
The map shows “Scarboro” shoal.
This is a digital reproduction from the private collection of Atty. Anne Marie Corominas of Manila and Cebu.

CARTE HYDROGRAPHIQUE & CHOROGRAPHIQUE DES ISLES PHILIPPINES

a113_.1792.3062
“CARTE HYDROGRAPHIQUE & CHOROGRAPHIQUE DES ISLES PHILIPPINES”(1792×3062) Published in 1760 in Nuremberg by George M. Lowitz based on the Murillo map although there is no such acknowledgment in the map.
The map shows “Panacot” shoal.
This digital reproduction is from Barry Lawrence Ruderman Antique Maps, Inc. (http://www.raremaps.com/ gallery/detail/35555/Carte_Hydrographique_ and_Chorographique_des_Isles_Philippines _Dediee_a_Sa/LowitzHomann%20Heirs.html).

A GENERAL MAP OF THE EAST INDIES AND THAT PART OF CHINA WHERE THE EUROPEANS HAVE ANY SETTLEMENTS OR COMMONLY ANY TRADE

a114_.1792.1256
“A GENERAL MAP OF THE EAST INDIES AND THAT PART OF CHINA WHERE THE EUROPEANS HAVE ANY SETTLEMENTS OR COMMONLY ANY TRADE” (1792×1256) Published in 1761 in London by the map maker Thomas Kitchin.
The map shows “Panacot” shoal.
This digital reproduction is from Barry Lawrence Ruderman Antique Maps, Inc. (http://www.raremaps. com/gallery/detail/0176gh/A_General_Map_of_the_ East_Indies_and_that_Part_of_China_
where_the_ Europeans/Kitchin.html).

A NEW MAP OF THE PHILIPPINE ISLANDS, DRAWN FROM THE BEST AUTHORITIES

a115_.6400.4581
“A NEW MAP OF THE PHILIPPINE ISLANDS, DRAWN FROM THE BEST AUTHORITIES” Published in 1769 in London by Thomas Kitchin.
The map shows “Panacot” shoal.
This digital reproduction is from the private collection of Atty. Anne Marie Corominas of Manila and Cebu.

EAST INDIES

a115_.6400.4581
“EAST INDIES” (6400×4581) Published in 1770 in London by Thomas Kitchin, the then Royal Hydrographer.
The map shows “Panacot” shoal.
This digital reproduction is from the National Library of Australia (Bib ID 3620673, map-rm1424).

A CHART OF THE CHINA SEA

a116_.9216.11655
“A CHART OF THE CHINA SEA” (9216×11655) Published in 1775 in Paris by D’Apres de Mannevillette.
The map shows “Scarboro” shoal.
The British tea clipper Scarborough struck the rocks of the shoal on 12 September 1748, and so European cartographers named the shoal Scarborough. This digital reproduction is from the National Library of Australia (Bib ID 3770071, map- ra49-s32).

“A CHART OF THE CHINA SEA AND THE PHILIPPINE ISLANDS WITH THE ARCHIPELAGOS OF FELICIA AND SOLOO”

a117_.7168.8869
“A CHART OF THE CHINA SEA AND THE PHILIPPINE ISLANDS WITH THE ARCHIPELAGOS OF FELICIA AND SOLOO” (7168×8869) Published in 1778 in London by R. Sayer and J. Bennett. Interestingly, “Panacot or Marsingola Bank” is the name given to one feature and “Scarborough Shoal” is the name given to a nearby shoal, with the words “the Scarborough Sept. 12, 1748,” the date when the British tea clipper struck the shoal.
This digital reproduction is from the National Library of Australia (Bib ID 3667413, map-ra52-s70).

“CARTE DE LA PARTIE ORIENTALE DES PHILIPPINES AND CARTE DE LA PARTIE OCCIDENTALE DES PHILIPPINES”

a117_.7168.8869
“CARTE DE LA PARTIE ORIENTALE DES PHILIPPINES AND CARTE DE LA PARTIE OCCIDENTALE DES PHILIPPINES” Published in 1781 in Paris by Gaitte, A.J. Two maps together forming a map of the Philippines, with upper left corner inset: Trombe Marine. Engraved by A.J. Gaitte and included in volume II of Le Gentil de la Galaisière’s voyage dans les Mers de L’Inde. The map shows B. de Masingolo. This is a digital reproduction from the private collection of Atty. Anne Marie Corominas of Manila and Cebu.


“MAP OF THE PACIFIC OCEAN BETWEEN THE COAST OF CALIFORNIA AND MEXICO AND JAPAN, PHILIPPINES, AND THE COAST OF CHINA”

a118_.20480.6172
“MAP OF THE PACIFIC OCEAN BETWEEN THE COAST OF CALIFORNIA AND MEXICO AND JAPAN, PHILIPPINES, AND THE COAST OF CHINA” (20480×6172) Published in 1784 with the watermark PVL (Pieter van Ley).
This map shows a shoal named “B. Mansiloc.”
This digital reproduction is from the U.S. Library of Congress (Catalog No. 91680984, Digital ID g9230 Ih000015).

ISOLE FILIPPINE

a119_.4608.5907
MAP 40. “ISOLE FILIPPINE” (4608×5907) Published in 1785 in Venice by Antonio Zatta. This map is based on the Murillo map although there is no such acknowledgment in the map.
“Panacot” shoal appears on this map as in the Murillo map.
This digital reproduction is from Barry Lawrence Ruderman Antique Maps, Inc. (http:// www.raremaps.com/gallery/detail/33827).

“SECONDE PARTIE DE LA CARTE D’ASIE” or Second Part of the Map of Asia 

a119_.4608.5907
“SECONDE PARTIE DE LA CARTE D’ASIE” or Second Part of the Map of Asia Published in 1786 in Paris by Jean Baptiste B. D’Anville as part of his Atlas de D’Anville. The map shows Sumatra, Java, Borneo, Moluccas, Philippines and Japan. The first part of the map of Asia is basically the 1734 China map of D’Anville. D’Anville’s Atlas was later re-printed by Robert Sayer, Laurie and Whittle and others. This map shows “Panacot” shoal.
In the later reprinted maps of Sayer, and Laurie and Whittle, Panacot is called Scarborough shoal.
This digital reproduction is from the National Library of Australia (Bib ID 3664337,Bib ID 1372672, map-ra 39).

A NEW CHART OF THE INDIAN AND PACIFIC OCEANS BETWEEN THE CAPE OF GOOD HOPE, NEW HOLLAND AND JAPAN

a120_.9728.6679
“A NEW CHART OF THE INDIAN AND PACIFIC OCEANS BETWEEN THE CAPE OF GOOD HOPE, NEW HOLLAND AND JAPAN” (9728×6679) Published in 1787 in London by Robert Sayer.
This map shows “Scarboro” shoal.
This digital reproduction is from the National Library of Australia (Bib ID 3507852, map-rm-451).

MAPA DE LAS ISLAS FILIPINAS

a120_.9728.6679
“MAPA DE LAS ISLAS FILIPINAS” Published in 1790 in Madrid by Duque de Almodóvar.
The map shows “Bco de Masingolo o’ Panacot”.
This is a digital reproduction from the private collection of Atty. Anne Marie Corominas of Manila and Cebu.

1792 CHART “PLANO DE LA NAVIGACION

a121_.3840.2671
1792 CHART “PLANO DE LA NAVIGACION’ is the route of the navigation taken by Alessandro Malaspina’s ship Sta. Lucia when Malaspina surveyed what is stated in the map as ‘Bajo Masinloc o Scarborough.” Published in Madrid by the Direccion de Hidrografia from the surveys of the Malaspina Expedition. On 4 May 1792, the day he surveyed Bajo de Masinloc, Malaspina wrote in his Journal ‘on (this shoal) Spanish and foreign ships have been lost.’
This digital reproduction is from the archives of the Museo Naval de Madrid, copied by the Philippine Embassy in Madrid.

ASIA AND ITS ISLANDS ACCORDING TO D’ANVILLE

u_.4352.3535
“ASIA AND ITS ISLANDS ACCORDING TO D’ANVILLE” (4352×3535) Published in 1794 in London by Robert Laurie and James Whittle. The map says that the delineations and discoveries made by Captain Cook are incorporated in the map.
The map shows “Scarborough” shoal.
This digital reproduction is from the National Library of Australia (Bib ID 2133866, map-rm 1865).

A NEW CHART OF THE CHINA SEA AND ITS SEVERAL ENTRANCES

a125_.7424.10819
“A NEW CHART OF THE CHINA SEA AND ITS SEVERAL ENTRANCES” (7424×10819) Published in 1802 in London by Robert Laurie and James Whittle.
This map shows “Scarborough” shoal, with the words “Scarborough Sept. 12th, 1748 and “the Negroes Head.”
This digital reproduction is from the National Library of Australia (Bib ID 3620691, map-rm 1425).

CARTA GENERAL DEL ARCHIPIELAGO DE FILIPINAS

a126_.11776.8063
“CARTA GENERAL DEL ARCHIPIELAGO DE FILIPINAS” (11776×8063) Published in 1808 in Madrid by the Direccion de Hidrografia from the surveys of the Malaspina Expedition.
The shoal is called “Bajo de Masingloc” but the map also adds “o Scarborough.”
This digital reproduction is from the archives of the Museo Naval de Madrid, copied by the Philippine Embassy in Madrid.

EAST INDIA ISLANDS ON MERCATOR’S PROJECTION

a127_.3072.2522
 “EAST INDIA ISLANDS ON MERCATOR’S PROJECTION” (3072×2522) Published between 1814 and 1832 in London by Thomas Kelly.
The map shows “Scarboro” shoal.
This digital reproduction is from the National Library of Australia (Bib ID 1493073, map-rm 2639).
a129_.8960.6348
“ASIA” (8960×6348) Published in 1818 in Philadelphia, USA by John Pinkerton.
The map shows “Scarborough” shoal.
This digital reproduction is from the U.S. Library of Congress (Catalog No. 2006636622, Digital ID g7400 ct1990).

ISLAS FILIPINAS

a130_.10752.7992
“ISLAS FILIPINAS” (10752×7992) Published in 1852 in Madrid by D. Antonio Morata and D. Francisco Coello.
This map shows “Bajo Masinloc.”
This digital reproduction is from the National Library of Australia (Bib ID 3639193, map-rm 1608).

CARTA GENERAL DEL ARCHIPIELAGO FILIPINO

a131_.4096.2793
“CARTA GENERAL DEL ARCHIPIELAGO FILIPINO” (4096×2793) Published in 1867 in Madrid by the Direccion de Hidrograpfica, this map is entitled “Carta General del Archipielago Filipino.”
This map shows “Bajo Masingloc o Scarborough.” There is an inset of Scarborough shoal (1866 map of Commander Wilds) on the lower left side of the map.
This digital reproduction is from the archives of the Museo Naval de Madrid, copied by the Philippine Embassy in Madrid.

CARTA ESFERICA DEL OCEANO INDIO

a132_.11520.7753
“CARTA ESFERICA DEL OCEANO INDIO” (11520×7753) Published in 1865 in Madrid by the Direccion de Hidrografia.
The map shows “B. Masingloc.”
This digital reproduction is from the National Library of Australia (Bib ID 122670, map-rm 2237).

PLANO DEL BAJO MASINGLOC

a133_.3072.2525
“PLANO DEL BAJO MASINGLOC” (3072×2525) Published in 1866 by E. Wilds, the Commander of the English warship Swallow, this map is entitled “Plano del Bajo Masingloc.”
This digital reproduction is from the archives of the Museo Naval de Madrid, copied by the Philippine Embassy in Madrid.

CARTA GENERAL DEL OCEANO INDICO

a134_.11520.7812
 “CARTA GENERAL DEL OCEANO INDICO” (11520×7812) Published in 1871 in Madrid by the Seccion de Hidrografia.
The map shows “B. Masingloc.”
This digital reproduction is from the National Library of Australia (Bib ID 2823213, map-rm 2235).

CARTA GENERAL DEL ARCHIPIELAGO FILIPINO

a135_.4096.2680
“CARTA GENERAL DEL ARCHIPIELAGO FILIPINO” (4096×2680) Published in 1875 in Madrid by the Direccion de Hidrografia.
This map shows “B. Masingloc o Scarborough.”
This digital reproduction is from the archives of the Museo Naval de Madrid, copied by the Philippine Embassy in Madrid.

CARTA GENERAL DEL OCEANO PACIFICO

a136_.7424.10982
“CARTA GENERAL DEL OCEANO PACIFICO” (7424×10982) Published in 1897 in Madrid by the Seccion de Hidrografia.
This map shows “B. Masingloc o Scarborough.”
This digital reproduction is from the National Library of Australia (Bib ID 1449962, map-rm3380).

ISLAS FILIPINAS – MAPA GENERAL – OBSERVATORIO DE MANILA”

a137_.5120.6025
“ISLAS FILIPINAS – MAPA GENERAL – OBSERVATORIO DE MANILA” (5120×6025) Published in 1899 in Washington, D.C. by the Jesuit Jose P. Algue and the U.S. Coast and Geodetic Survey.
The map shows “B. Masinloc.”
This digital reproduction is from the Atlas de Filipinas, Internet Archive, Ohio State University Library, (https://archive.org/stream/ AtlasDeFilipinasColleccionDe30
MapasTrabajadosPorDelineantes/ AtlasDeFilipinas#page/n27/mode/1up).

MAP OF THE PHILIPPINE ISLANDS

a138_.12288.16811
MAP OF THE PHILIPPINE ISLANDS (12288.16811) Published in 1908 in Baltimore, MD U.S.A. by Caspar Hodgson.
The map shows “Scarborough” shoal.
This digital reproduction is from the U.S. Library of Congress (Catalog No. 2013590196, Digital ID g8060 ct003965).

From the 1960s to the 1980s, U.S. military warplanes, together with Philippine Air Force warplanes, used Scarborough Shoal as an impact range when they practiced bombing runs. Neither China nor any other country protested these bombing practices by American and Philippine warplanes, despite worldwide prior Notices to Mariners, through the International Maritime Organization of the United Nations, to keep away from Scarborough Shoal during the bombing practices.

PHILIPPINE ISLANDS

a139_.10464.15155
“PHILIPPINE ISLANDS” (10464×15155) Published in 1933 and reissued in 1940 in Washington, D.C. by the U.S. Coast and Geodetic Survey.
The map shows “Scarborough” shoal with depth soundings.
This digital reproduction is from the U.S. Library of Congress (Catalog No. 2011592026; Digital ID g8061p ct003542).

If the Philippines can bomb a shoal repeatedly over decades without any protest from neighboring states, it certainly must have sovereignty over such shoal.

Carta Hydrographica Y Chorographica de las Yslas Filipinas

a112_.8407.7734
 “Carta Hydrographica Y Chorographica de las Yslas Filipinas” (8407×7734) Published in 1734 in Manila by the Jesuit Pedro Murillo, this is the oldest map that gives a name to “Panacot” shoal. “Panacot” is the Tagalog word for threat or danger. This map names two Filipinos, Francisco Suarez who drew the map and Nicolas dela Cruz Bagay who engraved it. This map is considered the “mother of all Philippine maps.”
This digital reproduction is from the U.S. Library of Congress (Catalog No. 2013585226; Digital ID g8060 ct003137)